Welcome to Friends of Florida and Monroe
Is Iberdrola's Hoosac Wind Project Right for Our Beautiful Berkshire Rural Landscape?
The Hoosac Wind Project is located in Florida and Monroe Massachusetts. The nineteen 340 foot tall industrial scale wind turbines make it the largest land-based wind project in the state.
The Friends of Florida and Monroe is a group of concerned citizens who question the wisdom of building a project like this. We are concerned about what life will be like for us living in close proximtiy to the turbines. We question whether or not the millions of dollars of public subsidies really benefit the public or is this an example of sucessful lobbyists lining the pockets of wealthy corporations? Will there be health effects from the turbines, and will we see a reduction of our property values? Do industrial scale wind turbines really help with global warming and help us get off fossil fuels? Or is this a wrong turn on the path to a sustainable energy future.
Please join us in learning more about industrial wind turbines. And help us to ensure the health and safety of the residents of Monroe and Florida, Massachusetts.
The Hoosac Wind Hotline in up and running!
Call 413-499-8336 if Noise from the wind project is too loud for you
Hoosac Wind - ACO 12.19.14 Final.pdf
Adobe Acrobat document [941.5 KB]
January 26, 2015 - The Hoosac Wind Hotline number is up and running. It is 413-499-8336 and I was told Iberdrola was posting it in Town Halls and sending it by mail to neighbors.
Calling the number during an episode of high noise will bring a technician to the site of concern to monitor and report on the noise conditions to determine if the noise is within the 10 dBA guideline or not. Monitoring will not be done if the episode has passed such as if a complainant calls the following day. Also if a complainant calls three times and each time the complaint is determined to be unfounded the technician is no longer required to respond to that specific complainant in the event of future complaints.
Office of State Representative Gailanne M. Cariddi
State House – Room 155
Boston, MA 02133
QUESTIONS ARISE ABOUT MASS DEP ORDERED SOUND TESTING PERFORMED IN RESPONSE TO COMPLAINTS
Steve Ambrose to Mass DEP - "I am amazed that a professional acoustician with decades of experience can be replaced by someone with an 8-hour training course. Mr. Littles lack of experience is clearly shown by half the data needing to be deleted because nearby conversations were permitted during measurements. The presented data clearly indicates high probability for exceeding the MassDEP noise limits. Wind turbines produce the highest noise level when at full power output, which needs to be reported. Full rpm is not equivalent to full power output. Therefore, these measurements do not represent actual conditions."
Hoosac sound testing -Ambrose response t[...]
Microsoft Word document [14.7 KB]
February 16, 2015 - I have reviewed the Sound Monitoring Report Summary prepared by RSG. The remarks section acknowledges that measurements were contaminated and interrupted with conversations, car noise and instrument calibration. The third-party sound monitor is not identified with qualifications. RSG is the acoustical consultant for Iberdrola.
Adobe Acrobat document [713.9 KB]
February 19, 2015 Thank you for forwarding to me Stephen Ambrose’s critique of our February 5 sound monitoring report for Hoosac.
Hoosac Wind - RSG memo to DEP 02-17-2015[...]
Adobe Acrobat document [65.9 KB]
Hoosac Wind Project Noise is Out of Compliance; The Remedy is Not Working for Neighbors
December 7, 2014
Sent to Mass DEP by e-mail:
The new additions DID NOT help the noise coming at us last night...VERY LOUD still ...Is there going to be follow up testing to see if this project is under state guidelines? How will you evaluate is further testing is not scheduled...? This project still continues to bother us...and not just when there is icing condititions....but I'm telling you ...these serated edges did not diminish the noise comming at us much ....if at all ??
Please plan more testing , and not just during icing
Friends of Florida & Monroe
Wind Turbines Don't Run on Wind-They Run on Subsidies
Shirley (Wisconsin) Wind Human Health Hazard Declaration
Request for Words of Support
Posted: December 8, 2014
At the October 14, 2014 Brown County Board of Health meeting a motion was made to declare the Shirley Wind turbines a Human Health Hazard. The following motion was unanimously approved by the Board:
"To declare the Industrial Wind Turbines at Shirley Wind Project in the Town of Glenmore, Brown County, WI. A Human Health Hazard for all people (residents, workers, visitors, and sensitive passersby) who are exposed to Infrasound/Low Frequency Noise and other emissions potentially harmful to human health."
Brown County is located in Wisconsin, USA.
Brown County Citizens for Responsible Wind Energy (BCCRWE) has issued a press release regarding this Human Health Hazard declaration, which can be seen at: http://bccrwe.com/index.php/8-news/16-duke-energy-s-shirley-wind-declared-human-health-hazard BCCRWE is requesting your words of support for this action.
Research indicates that industrial wind turbines can negatively affect the physical, mental and social well-being of individuals if placed too close to homes. BCCRWE has been working intensively for the past 5 years with professional researchers, physicians, acousticians, and legislators to protect citizens of Brown County, the state of Wisconsin, the United States, and those in other countries from the negative health impacts resulting from industrial wind turbines being built too close to people.
BCCRWE welcomes and encourages individuals, organizations, and governmental agencies from around the world to send their words of support regarding the Board of Health's action. BCCRWE will pass your emails on to the Brown County Board of Health as support for their courage, integrity, responsibility, intellectual honesty, and care in declaring the industrial wind turbines at Shirley Wind to be human health hazards.
If you or others you know have experienced negative health impacts from living in close proximity to industrial wind turbines and would like to share that experience along with your words of support with the Brown County Board of Health, please do so.
Send your words of support, and if applicable your experiences, to: BOHsupport@bccrwe.com
Brown County Citizens for Responsible Wind Energy
HOOSAC WIND TURBINES VIOLATE STATE NOISE STANDARDS
August 2, 2014 - These industrial wind turbines are out of compliance much more than the two days of isolated testing that Research System Group did after we complained about the noise here. WHAT ABOUT THE OTHER 363 days a year? Just because they aren't being tested DOES NOT mean that they are IN compliance. We need help to make sure this project is held to STATE GUIDELINES every day of the year - or shut it down.
While Iberdrola would like to assure the public otherwise, we have every reason to believe that the wind turbines near our homes will continue to be loud. They will continue alter our once quiet and peaceful existence here on Moore's Road, severely impacting our health, well-being and property values. They are way too close to many homes here in Florida and all the surrounding towns. And sadly, the ones near us are right on over the town line in Monroe, so we never had a say about them.
Wisconsin Health Board Declares Wind Turbines "a human health hazard"
<< New text box >>
By DIANE BRONCACCIO
Friday, August 1, 2014
(Published in print: Saturday, August 2, 2014)
MONROE — Acoustic testing of the Hoosac Wind turbines in Monroe and Florida show that noise levels have exceeded the maximum decibel range permissible for the 19-turbine New England Wind facility.
Hoosac Recorder aug 1, 2014.doc
Microsoft Word document [43.5 KB]
REPORT FINDS HOOSAC TURBINES OUT OF COMPLIANCE
Jim Jevulis July 31, 2014 WAMC Northeast Public Radio
Studies done earlier this year show noise levels coming from wind turbines at the Hoosac Wind Project in northwestern Massachusetts were out of compliance with state regulations. People living in the area have complained of adverse health impacts since the turbines began spinning in 2012.
Prepared for Iberdrola Renwables
Hoosac Monitoring Report 04-29-2014.pdf
Adobe Acrobat document [682.8 KB]
Letter to Massachusetts DEP from Iberdrola May 2, 2014
Hoosac Wind Transmittal Letter 5-2-14.pd[...]
Adobe Acrobat document [604.0 KB]
Forum on Industrial Wind and Property Values
Forum on Industrial Wind Considers Property Values
Slated for January 17 in Grafton, Vermont
DANBY, VT—A public forum on the impact of industrial wind towers on property values will take place on Friday, January 17, at 6:30 p.m. at the White Church, 55 Main Street, Grafton. This is the second of three forums on Wind Development in Rural Communities sponsored by Vermonters for a Clean Environment, a statewide not-for-profit organization.
Michael McCann, a professional real estate appraiser, will be the main speaker. McCann is a Chicago based appraiser who has studied and appraised wind project impacts on property values from coast to coast, and has qualified and testified as an expert witness on this subject before various zoning boards, siting committees and litigated cases.
He brings 8 years of wind experience to Grafton on January 17, and will provide vital insight into the growing evidence of value impacts. He will inform attendees regarding appropriate methodology for such evaluations that meet professional and legal standards of evidence. He will present examples of independent value study results as well as wind industry funded studies, and provide a better understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of different methodologies used.
Seminar attendees are advised that McCann is an unbiased professional, and is not an anti-wind spokesman or activist as some in the pro-wind industry have characterized him. His blunt and transparent studies have, however, effectively debunked the industry claim of “NO VALUE IMPACT”.
Joining Mike on the panel will be Vermont residents who live near the wind turbine project on Georgia Mountain and have experienced first-hand the impact on their property values. Annette Smith, Executive Director of VCE will facilitate.
Iberdrola Renewables, the fourth largest energy company in the world, has recently erected three MET towers (test towers), two in Windham and one in Grafton on land owned by New Hampshire-based Meadowsend Timberlands Limited. The towers are likely a precursor to an application for Windham County’s first utility-scale wind turbine development.
All are welcome to attend this free event. Pizza and beverages will be served.
The next forum on the impacts of industrial wind will be held on Friday evening, February 21.
Vermonters for a Clean Environment is a statewide non-profit environmental advocacy organization that focuses on ensuring citizens have a voice in the permitting, regulatory, and legislative processes.
Iberdrola's avian consultant fined and sentenced for federal wildlife violations.
Dec 30, 2013 --Iberdrola wildlife consultant fined-
“We support the Justice Department’s vigilance in prosecuting Bittner for his serious transgressions and unlawful behavior,” said Tisdale, who has long contended that there are eagles in areas slated for wind turbines, where Bittner claims there are none. ““When unethical and basically corrupt experts like Bittner side with industry over avian protection,” Tisdale concluded, “our beautiful birds literally get clobbered with the blunt end of the turbine blade.”
David Bittner, was sentenced in federal court in August after pleading guilty to unlawful taking a Golden Eagle without a permit and failing to file any data reports for a four-year period on birds that he had banded.
Bittner was sentenced to probation and a $7,500 fine.Critics called that a slap on the wrist, since Bittner and the Wildlife Research Institute had raked in more than $600,000 in consulting fees for his work on behalf of large energy companies. Iberdrola and Pattern Energy hired him to write reports justifying their wind projects, Tule Wind in McCain Valley and the Ocotillo Express Wind Facility. Sempra Energy also hired Bittner as its eagle consultant for its massive Energia Sierra Juarez Wind in Baja California.
Wind Siting Standards Hearing- Monday January 27 5pm-8pm Pittsfield, MA
Adobe Acrobat document [164.1 KB]
DPU hearing Time and Place
Berkshire Community College
Monday, January 27, 2014
5:00 - 8:00 pm (longer, if necessary)
Koussevitzky Arts Center, Room K-110
1350 West Street, Pittsfield, MA 01201
Direction and Campus Map
Accoustics Expert -People matter, not sound testing equipment December 22, 2013
Ambrose said “we have to end up putting at the top of our list human complaints–that’s why we’re all here. If we end up putting our instruments there, we’re not going to end up solving the human complaint problem.”
Wind Noise Forum, Townshend, VT November 22, 2013
A discussion about noise and health effects of industrial wind with an expert and residents living near wind turbines.
Hosted by VT State Senator Peter Galbraith D-Windham
With Steven Ambrose, a civil engineer and member of the Institute of Noise Control Engineering
And Citizens from Groton, NH and the communities around the Hoosac WInd Project in Massachusetts
Hoosac Sound Testing Challenged by Wind Noise Experts
November 22, 2013- Stephen Ambrose and Robert Rand
A case study in sound testing after a wind turbine project is operating, and the neighbors complain. The review concludes that Mass DEP sound regulat
hoosac-wind-turbine-noise-studies rand a[...]
Adobe Acrobat document [3.6 MB]
The sound studies for Hoosac Wind Project were arranged for by MASS DEP and paid for by the developer. The residents near the project had many questions regarding the legitimacy of this study.
Hoosac Cover Letter_FInal Sound study.pd[...]
Adobe Acrobat document [94.9 KB]
Published in June, 2013 by Resources Systems Group, Inc of Vermont. The study concluded that the turbines are in compliance with MASS DEP sound regulations
Hoosac Sound Monitoring Report 6-27-2013[...]
Adobe Acrobat document [4.2 MB]
Mr. Rand refutes the study results, suggesting that Hoosac Wind probably exceeds State noise limits. As noise level increases with power output, the highest sound levels were likely not acquired.
Hoosac Wind review-Rand.pdf
Adobe Acrobat document [1.1 MB]
The data is not representative of full-power output. . The background ambient noise levels were contaminated with tree and wind rustle, which can increase noise by more than the state standard.
Hoosac wind study review -ambrose.pdf
Adobe Acrobat document [224.4 KB]
Will State Noise Standards Help You? - DON'T COUNT ON IT
FARIHAVEN- SEPTEMBER 10, 2013 If town residents agree on anything, it's that the turbine fight is likely not over. In fact the State of Massachusetts is still
investigating the turbines, as well, after determining they were too
loud and exceeded legal noise levels, on a number of occasions.
FALMOUTH SEPTEMBER 17, 2013
By a 3-2 vote last night at the Falmouth Public Library selectmen voted a
long-range plan for the wind turbines at the Wastewater Treatment
Facility, electing to increase the operation for both machines from 12
hours per day to 16 hours per day.
A Comment for this article states that "There is no mention in the article that Wind-1 was found by state regulators to be generating over 50 decibels of offensive
noise 1,320 feet away. Falmouth bylaws limit noise to 40 decibels. The typical
ambient sound level in Falmouth is around 30 decibels."
Residents report on noise from wind turbines of Hoosac Wind Project
FLORIDA - Residents living near the Hoosac Wind Project held a press conference Tuesday, where they discussed formal complaints they have filed with the state Department of Environmental Protection
Hoosac Wind turbines NA Trans 2-13-13.do[...]
Microsoft Word document [245.5 KB]
FLORIDA, Mass. — The stories they tell are similar — constant headaches, ringing ears, pounding hearts, sleepless nights.
The cause of their concern can be seen sweeping the sky
Hoosac Wind turbines i berks 2-12-12.doc
Microsoft Word document [299.0 KB]
“My quiet, peaceful, serene world and home has been turned into a reeling of unending noise, annoyance and constant dealing with those in charge to help us,” said Fairneny. “My wife’s ears are
hoosac Recorder 12-13-13.doc
Microsoft Word document [57.5 KB]
BERKSHIRE COUNTY, Mass. -- "At night, at 3 a.m., 4 a.m. in the morning, it sounds like it's worse. It sounds like helicopters idling in the woods," said Mark Lavariere, a resident of Florida.
hoosac WTEN ALBANY NY 2-12-12.doc
Microsoft Word document [52.0 KB]
ARE YOU CONCERNED ABOUT WIND TURBINES IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD?
The noise and vibration from large wind turbines have been
shown to have serious health effects. People all across our State are
complaining. People in nearby Vermont and New York are experiencing
a loss of peace and quiet in their rural homes. People living near turbines are reporting
insomnia, headaches, dizziness, heart palpitations, emotional depression and
constant stress. The sounds and
vibrations are even worse when people are inside their homes.
And we have the largest turbine project in Massachusetts!
Call Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection
413-784-1100 or e-mail email@example.com
If they don’t hear from you, they will be forced to assume that you don’t care about the noise and vibration that you are being subjected to.
Here is a form that you can fill out, save the changes and e-mail to DEP. Or use as a guideline for your call in complaint or download and mail it in.
Hoosac complaint form.doc
Microsoft Word document [40.0 KB]
Governor Patrick is Met By Protesters at Hoosac Wind "Celebration"
Governor celebrates Hoosac Wind Project December 3, 2012
Letters to the Editor
These facts eclipse all other facets of the debate about wind power in that they challenge the very core of widely held assumptions about what we can really accomplish with wind energy. When so little is gained, why is it worth the massive public subsidies, impact on neighbors, wildlife, etc? Lloyd Crawford
… in inland New England, IWTs will not reduce our carbon footprint. They will not contribute in any way toward limiting global warming. They will however significantly increase the cost of every person’s and business’s electricity, precisely at a time when we cannot afford it. The reason is that the subsidies paid to keep this economically unsustainable technology operating will be spread over everyone’s monthly electric bill, in addition to the cost of the normal fossil-fuel-based capacity required to back-up those IWTs. Raymond Hartman
Michael Fairneny (left) of Florida and Malcolm Donald (second from left) of Falmouth wait for their meeting with the Governor while State wind turbine proponents admire the view.
“I feel like my whole world is going to turn to crap,” said Farineny, who has lived in his home for 28 years.“We were told we would never even see these things, and now I’m afraid we’re going to hear them.” (Gazettenet.com)
Protesters are on hand to help educate our public officials.
"Lloyd Crawford, of Hawley, is concerned with the new wind turbines not addressing the state's current energy problems."This project produces one 1,000th of the electricity used in
Massachusetts,"he said. "Power demand is expected to grow one percent per year for the next
decade. We'd have to put up a project like this once every 5 weeks for the next 10 years just to keep up with demand." (North Adams Transcript)
ALBANY, N.Y. (CN) - Dozens of neighbors of a $200 million wind farm sued the companies behind it,
Residents sue wind developer Iberdrola i[...]
HTML document [17.0 KB]
NEWS FROM VERMONT
From Lowell Mountain, Vermont
From the Caldonian Record - October 8, 2012
lowell mountain noise compaints.zip
Compressed archive in ZIP format [544.5 KB]
On October 10, the Florida Massachusetts Selectmen heard from residents,
calling themselves “The Friends of Florida and Monroe”, concerned about
the Hoosac Wind Project that is scheduled to go online later this year.
October 10, 2012- Residents of Florida express their concerns about possible noise problems from the Hoosac Wind Project to the Florida Selectmen and to representatives from wind developer Iberola
Compressed archive in ZIP format [33.0 MB]
North Adams Transcript October 11, 2012
New Wind Turbines Pose Noise Concerns in Florida
NorthAdams.com October 2, 2012
FLORIDA, Mass. — Residents will be able to bring questions and concerns to the developers of the Hoosac Wind Project next week.
North Adams Transcript Monday September 24, 2012
FLORIDA -- All 19 wind turbines are up, and the testing and commissioning process is about to begin on Bakke Mountain in Florida and Crum Hill in Monroe -- the final step before the Hoosac Wind project can start generating power.
Sep 10, 2012 ... A 19-turbine industrial wind farm is near completion in the Northern Berkshires, but according to nearby residents, some uncertainties about the ...
An overview of issues with industrial wind power.
Find More Information Here
Please visit these websites to find out more about industrial wind
On Facebook Please Visit
Green Berkshires Wind Wise Radio
Falmouth Turbine Neighbors
Friends of Grafton's Heritage
Must See Video From Vermont
This video was made in Vermont, but is equally relevant to Massachusetts